
Joseph Campbell (1904-1987) was a philosopher whose main concentration was comparative mythology. As we look to Campbell for guidance on war and peace, Gentle Reader, you might want to remember I am to understanding Campbell as a reporter is to understanding Artificial Intelligence. The same sort of puzzlement you may experience after reading my analysis of Campbell’s recitation of the age-old mythology of war is what I feel when a reporter with a degree in English stumbles around A.I. with Geoffrey Hinton. In other words, one would be prudent to rely on their own conclusions rather than to simply elide over mine when Campbell’s higher thoughts are an issue. With that product warning, let’s dive in.
Campbell wrote many books on mythology. One of my favorites is Myths to Live By. It is only 276 pages long. However, if you are like me, it will take you as long to digest it as it would James Joyce’s Ulysses. On the other hand, Myths to Live By is much more useful and interesting than Ulysses and, frankly, easier to understand.
In Campbell’s chapter on the “Mythologies of War and Peace” Campbell sets forth his central thesis as follows:
“For it is a basic idea of practically every war mythology that the enemy is a monster and that in killing him one is protecting the only truly valuable order of human life on earth, which is that, of course, of one’s own people.”
Campbell juxtaposes this philosophy with that of the great German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860). Campbell cites to Schopenhauer’s essay “The Foundation of Morality” in which Schopenhauer asks:
“How is it that an individual can so forget himself and his own safety that he will put himself and his life in jeopardy to save another from death or pain – as though that other’s life were his own, that other’s danger his own? Such a one is then acting out of an instructive recognition of the truth that he and that other in fact are one.”
Campbell says such actions occur because we occasionally recognize that we are all one. Such actions are motivated by the one and only inspiration of inherently moral action. For a moment one is selfless, boundless, without ego.
This epiphany that we are all one is what Jesus was preaching about. Or as John Donne (1572-1631) put it in his poem, For Whom the Bell Tolls:
“No man is an island, entire of itself; … any man’s death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind.”
So, the mythology of war is mainly between all “others” are monsters versus there are no “others” because we are all one. We must strive to defend ourselves and our fellow citizens from those “others” when they regard us as “the other”, but we will only achieve true peace when we and all “others” accept that we are one. While some defensive wars are still necessary for our survival, if we are to avoid extinguishing our species, we must accept all as we want them to accept us.
At least that’s what I got from Professor Campbell or I might have learned it by being horrified by the news. Of course, my wife Peg points out that other fine contemporary philosopher, John Lennon (1940-1980), said the same things in his song, Imagine. And it certainly is easier on the brain.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
Leave a Reply