• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

James M. Redwine

  • Books
  • Columns
  • 1878 Lynchings/Pogrom
  • Events
  • About

Football

N.I.L.

September 23, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

Photo by Peg Redwine

Congress is in a dither over college athletics. The Transfer Portal and Name, Image and Likeness have made such matters as our war against Iran and the cost of living irrelevant. The Senate’s pending Protect College Sports Act of 2026 (S 4668) is full of Sound and Fury about such civilization-ending matters as the ownership of quarterbacks, basketball centers and pitchers. One might think the 14th Amendment and slavery were still the salient issues of the day.

Who owns college athletes and how much should such indentured servants be paid by their university masters? More importantly, how much can colleges raise tuition on non-athletes to pay the stars? Where’s the loyalty? What about tradition? Does one’s alma mater matter? Most significantly, is a college degree of any more value than a certificate of honorable service for 4 years working the drive-thru window at McDonald’s?

We could place the blame for game-day tickets costing $600 plus a car payment equivalent for parking and a hot dog on coaches, fans and television. But, I suggest the responsibility for college athletics costing more than the Defense Budget rests squarely on the institutions themselves. Have they all forgotten how N.I.L. used to work before July 01, 2021 when the NCAA authorized payments to athletes?

We all remember the old days, well some of us do. Once pay for play was illegal and could result in Draconian punishment. The most egregious incident was when “the greatest amateur athlete in the world”, as King Gustav V of Sweden called Jim Thorpe, was stripped of his 1912 Olympic medals because he accepted $50 for playing one summer of semi-pro baseball.

Thorpe could have been treated as many “amateur” college players were. A star player might find a new car with his or her name on the title sitting in their driveway. Or a college might “hire” a player to do a non-existent job. No one seemed to care too much and the players always stayed at their alma mater until they graduated. Wealthy boosters supplemented the taxpayers’ funds. I did not play college sports but I did work at a college dormitory cafeteria; I had to show up.

I would prefer that Congress address $50,000 per year tuition and the often worthless degrees it buys. Universities are important to our democracy but mainly as havens for the free-flow of controversial ideas. I respectfully suggest we make all higher learning job specific and of 2-year duration. That’s assuming that all college students already know from prior public education how to read, write and respect the Constitution.

If some infatuated fat-cat fan wants to pay their money to buy his or her alma mater’s super star a Rolex or a jet plane, I do not see how that hurts me. However, if a public university does so, I say “throw a yellow flag!” And if a player wants to change schools, I say, “slavery went out with the 13th Amendment”.

You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: Football, Gavel Gamut Tagged With: amateur college players, football, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, Jim Thorpe, King Gustav V, N.I.L., Protect College Sports Act of 2026, slavery, throw a yellow flag, Transfer Portal

Chance Favors the Prepared

June 24, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

At the IU Bookstore. Photo taken by Peg Redwine

Roman soldiers cast lots, gambled, on which soldier would take Jesus’ tunic/robe (See John 19:22-29). The New Testament refers to this shameful activity to help portray the crucifixion as even more humiliating. Each of the Gospels mentions this story that helps set forth the evil of the event and how Jesus was demeaned. In other words, gambling is not an admired activity, at least when it comes to stealing the clothes of Jesus.

Indiana University had no knowledge of Brendan Sorsby’s gambling addiction while he played quarterback for IU his red-shirt freshman year of 2022. The NCAA informed Indiana University after Sorsby’s illness came to light while he played at Texas Tech; he had also played at Cincinnati after he left IU and gambled while there too, although there’s no evidence Cincinnati was aware of it.

In a podcast from Texas Tech, Tech’s president, Lawrence Schovanec, the head Athletic Director, Kirby Hocutt, the assistant AD, Grant Stovalle, and the head football coach, Joey McGuire, all defended the court decision that ruled against the NCAA’s ban of Sorsby from playing college sports. Their strong, collective position was that the most important issue was dealing with Sorsby’s gambling addiction. No mention was made of any potential harm to college sports.

If someone bets a beer on who will win the Rose Bowl, unless that someone is a player in the game, no harm results. However, if a quarterback bets thousands on his team to lose, questions should arise. It is not that people do not have sympathy and understanding of addictions. The difficulty is integrity of a college sporting contest as affected by the addiction. These must remain completely separate issues and should be dealt with accordingly. Help the former player deal with his or her mental problem but do not enable them to help tear down legitimate competition. In other words, ban them from college sports. They can still go pro if good enough and if they do not bet on the game.

I have no wish to see Brendan Sorsby’s life further destructed by his illness. I hope he gets treatment and that it is successful. However, I cannot help feeling great relief that Sorsby was not at IU in 2024-26 as we climbed out of obscurity to be national champions. We have suffered too many years of losing to see our moments of glory besmirched.

You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: Football, Gavel Gamut, Indiana University Tagged With: Brendan Sorsby, gambling addiction, Grant Stovalle, harm to college sports, Indiana University, James M. Redwine, Jesus' tunic, Jim Redwine, Joey McGuire, Kirby Hocutt, Lawrence Schovanec, New Testament, Roman soldiers, Rose Bowl, Texas Tech

Natural Law, Morality and Democracy

June 11, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

Our homo sapiens species has been around about two to three hundred thousand years. We probably began biologically in Africa with what we assert is our Western culture becoming ascendant in southern Europe about twenty-five hundred years ago. The Greeks and the Romans laid the foundation for our civilization and we still rely upon their theories of what a civilized society should be, especially in regard to morality and law.

History is replete with rising and falling societies that have gone from collectively agreed upon legal systems to usurpation of power by elites that caused the society to fall upon its own sword. While there are many reasons why each “eternal” nation collapsed, as Plato posited in his Republic, a society rules by consensus then by a ruling party in its own interests. The rulers define the laws based upon what the autocrats desire, then define anyone who breaks such laws a wrongdoer. This is the final stage of a great civilization. Law moves from a consensus among a majority of the citizens as to what is right and good to a decree from the powerful based upon what they want.

Thousands of years ago primitive societies found they could live better lives among themselves and with their neighbors if they cooperated on such matters as the sharing of natural resources and respect for the person and property of others. This was the beginning of morality; and still moral behavior by individuals and nations comes down to treating others as we wish to be treated. Gradually, such nascent civilizations came to realize that as Aristotle said, legal systems (laws) were necessary because people could not restrain desire for power. If people were perfect, laws would not be needed but, as we are not, to ensure justice we must have law. And if the laws remain just, a society can survive life’s inevitable chaos.

Such philosophers as Socrates, Plato and Aristotle believed the world was grounded in Natural Law. Law just existed as did gods. Mankind only needed to divine what the gods required and apply such rules to humanity. If mankind ignored this immutable Natural Law, then chaos would rein. This concept of the eternal existence of Natural Law was at the core of most of the great legal theories from the ancient Greeks up to our Founding Fathers and is still prevalent today in many countries. In America, we separated law from superstition and left it to individuals to believe or not. This separation of theocracy from democracy was a new concept 250 years ago and has helped preserve our nation through many moral crises such as the Civil War and political in-fighting today. The First Ten Amendments of our Constitution are the rock by which we thrive.

Experience has proven that relying on a fear of a god or gods to enforce laws fails in the face of human nature. We have found that it is human law that must set limits on the natural tendency of mankind to abuse power. Over the last twenty-five hundred years or so we have sought systems of law that restrain autocratic impulses and protect individual rights. The most successful of such systems so far has been the Separation of Powers legal system as set forth in the United States Constitution.

Our Constitution was not based on Natural Law but upon the theories of such visionaries as Baron de Montesquieu. (1689-1755), John Locke (1632-1704), and especially, James Madison (1751-1836) and James Wilson (1742-1798). Wilson not only was a contributing author to our Constitution but also sat on our first United States Supreme Court. These legal philosophers recognized the major problem of instituting a lasting democratic legal system was preventing autocrats from usurping powers that properly belong to the citizens.

The division of executive power and legislative power as a restraint on one another was not sufficient. The inclusion of a third branch of government, the judiciary, was the piece of the puzzle that our Founders devised to answer this fatal flaw that had occurred in other legal systems which had failed, because as power corrupted the leaders, democracy collapsed into tyranny. In America today, our Legislative Branch has generally abandoned its role of restraining our out-of-control Executive Branch and our Judicial Branch has sometimes not asserted proper restraints on both of the other branches.

Is America in a vulnerable position democratically today? Probably not, as yet. However, when the Executive repeatedly takes the country to war in spite of virtually every poll indicating a significant majority of the electorate objects, and the Legislative Branch is supine in its duties concerning the power to declare war and the Judiciary fiddles away, the will of the people is frustrated and democracy might teeter. This could be one of those times as Greece, Rome and numerous other democracies discovered when it is critical that all three branches not only stay in their lane but gird their Constitutional loins up about them and courageously execute their own Constitutionally defined responsibilities.

You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: America, Authors, Democracy, Football, Gavel Gamut Tagged With: Aristotle, democracy, executive branch, Founding Fathers, Greeks, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, judicial branch, legislative branch, Locke, Madison, Montesquieu, morality, natural law, Plato, Republic, Romans, Socrates, United States Constitution, Wilson

Legends

January 28, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

Photo by Peg Redwine

What turns a passing incident into a legend? Fear is often involved or at least, apprehension. Hatred perhaps or maybe just sublimated envy. Villains and heroes, sinners and saints, hangers-on and barely aware casual observers may be recognized or may be unnoticed. Accurate observations may be misidentified while surmise and self-fulfilling yearnings might be confused by societies distracted by the sturm und drang of living. What we can be assured is that an occasional legend is required if we are going to sublimate our daily ennui and manage to muddle through.

Great legends of history often arise on a “just-in-time, just-in-place” happenstance. Often, they appear as individuals but, more often, individuals are named while the legends involve groups. Military exploits such as Achilles and the Greeks at Troy, or Eisenhower and the Allies at D-Day are examples. Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King led, but many others also sacrificed. It is impossible to honor or even acknowledge the millions who contributed to the legends, so we usually coalesce upon one or a very few to crown with being the legend. There is nothing we can do about this human approach; we are human.

Another area we choose in which to anoint representative heroes is athletics. The legends are often only cogs in the great Circle of Life that helps the hero showcase his or her talents but who would not advance without many spokes supporting them. Fortunately, often our legends recognize and acknowledge these facts and often say so as they share the credit.

So, as we glorify Curt Cignetti and Fernando Mendoza and all the rest of the 2025-2026 Indiana Hoosier football team who are the College Football National Champions, as well we should, we should follow their lead and thank the many before them and along with them who helped them inspire us. Here’s to ball-boys, water-girls and the generous boosters among countless others such as IU’s administration.

One of the best attributes of current glory is, if our contemporary heroes have character, and these do, they acknowledge the foundation upon which they stand and often refer to our heroes of IU’s illustrious more than 200-year history. When the media dwells upon past losses we should remind the world of past glories. Indiana University was founded in 1820, not 2024.

When I would walk across the Indiana campus from the Law School to the Gables Restaurant, I often thought of that other law student, Hoagy Carmichael, who had been in there dreaming of “Stardust” when he probably was supposed to be trying to fathom the intricacies of Marbury v. Madison (1803). But what always drew my attention was the gigantic mural above the Gables lunch counter that portrayed our undefeated football team of 1945; war veterans who had helped save the world while enhancing IU’s proud history.

And another good aspect of our 2025-26 Rose Bowl Champions is their exploits recall those of our 1967-68 Rose Bowl team. It has been particularly gratifying to see Coach Lee Corso on TV giving credit to our 1979 Holiday Bowl victors. Neither Curt Cignetti nor countless others failed to honor our university’s long and proud history of culture and accomplishments. IU’s record of football losses is a mite in the pantheon of our proud traditions. Our 2025-26 team is our most recent reminder, we are not losers, we are Hoosiers!

The current chapter of the IU legend may be a new beginning or but a moment. Regardless, it is sure fun now and that is due to the efforts of a whole lot of other dreamers who are, after all these years, as amazed and gratified as Peg and I and the rest of the long cream and crimson line of co-commiserators and winners are.

 

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: Events, Football, Gavel Gamut, Indiana University Tagged With: College Football National Champions, cream and crimson, Curt Cignetti, Fernando Mendoza, Hoagy Carmichael, Indiana University 2025-26 football team, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, Lee Corso, legends, Stardust

Coach Cignetti, The Philosopher King

January 22, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

Curt Cignetti was hired to be Indiana University’s football coach beginning with the 2024 college football season. In 2022 IU’s record was four wins and eight losses. For 2023 it was three wins and nine losses. In 2024 IU lost two games, one in the College Football Playoffs, and won eleven. IU just won the College Football National Championship for 2025-26 by being the only undefeated college team and posting sixteen wins and zero losses. IU started 2025 as history’s losingest college football program based on over 700 losses. A couple of basic questions are: How did IU go from the whale dung of college football to Marathon type victors (490 BC) and who wrought this miracle?

Those are important issues to ponder. However, America is currently dealing with other much more important matters than sports. Perhaps we can learn something as a country by examining how Indiana University went in two years from football fodder to pundits accusing my alma mater of cheating to win games. That has been the ultimate unintended compliment from the envious. We are now so good we must have called upon the gods or stolen signs or somehow bought a championship with NIL money. Surely no mere educational ivory tower could turn southern Indiana limestone into football lemonade in only two years.

Dunn Meadow and the Little Jordan River must have been co-opted by trolls or John Mellencamp and Mark Cuban. Only magic and money could explain the college that lost its first game in 1887, then followed it with over 700 losses, to winning the National Championship on January 19, 2026. But, what if instead of just assuming this Hoosier triumph is but a logical lacuna, we try to learn something from IU and its miraculous turnaround that can be applied to help America out of its miasma.

Is it possible that Curt Cignetti and his staff are the Philosopher Kings of football whose methods should be applied to our democracy? As Plato recommended in his Republic, instead of us choosing our leaders on the basis of popularity created by promising to give stuff away or to conquer other countries because we want their stuff, maybe we should elect our leaders based on their character, ability and hard work as proven by their past performance. Maybe we need portals which incorruptible leaders could pass through to be rewarded for their proven public-spirited expertise; Name, Image and Likeness indeed, but most importantly, proven character!

Instead of our political leaders being voted into office based on the drivel of cackling TV panelists who hate or love whomever they are promoting or opposing, what if we citizens evaluate our future leaders as Coach Curt Cignetti and his staff did for our Indiana University football champions? Quality of past performance, not feckless promises of future nirvanas are the lodestone we voters can learn to follow based on the example of these 2026 Hoosiers. Too often five-star potential from our politicians metamorphosizes into a sense of entitlement without the sweat required for production. Maybe what America needs from its leaders is evidence of proven positive results based on performance. What if we stop mouthing MAGA and adopt for our motto: “Hoo, Hoo, Hoo, Hoosiers!”?

On Facebook follow us at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: America, Authors, Democracy, Football, Gavel Gamut Tagged With: ability, character, Coach Curt Cignetti, College Football National Championship, democracy, football, hard work, Hoo Hoo Hoo Hoosiers, Hoosier, incorruptible leaders, Indiana University, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, John Mellencamp, Mark Cuban, NIL, past performance, Philosopher King, Plato, Republic

Hallowed Halls of Laurel

January 14, 2026 by Peg Leave a Comment

Photo by Peg Redwine

HALLOWED HALLS OF LAUREL

It is kinda’ like how I felt when the sister and two brothers I grew up with became a college professor, a world-class musician and a leading legal scholar. Where did that come from? Gentle Reader, you probably have had the same puzzlement about the neighbor kid you played house or marbles with who is recognized later in life by others as brilliant. You most likely ask yourself, “Who snatched their body away and replaced them with this heroic icon?”

This Gavel Gamut could not be written until after Indiana University’s football team won the CFP semi-final game against Oregon on 09 January 2026; IU did! So, now the ultimate issue to be decided is, will IU beat Miami for the National Championship on Monday, January 19, 2026? In spite of the “rat poison curse”, I say they can and will have done so before you read this column. Miami is extremely well coached and talented, but IU is even better. Discipline and turnovers will decide the outcome. I submit no college football team is better disciplined nor as adept at causing and capitalizing upon their opponent’s mistakes as IU. Yeah, I cannot believe I am writing that either!

Now back to the theme of this column; where the devil did this come from to a program that was the first in college football history to lose over 700 games? What ironic quirk of athletic history brought the college I first saw lose in 1963 to, hopefully, the National Championship a lifetime later? I still remember countless games we lost in the fourth quarter, even in the last seconds of the fourth quarter, or because of some idiosyncratic football faux pas? Where is that team of hard striving ultimate losers who kept falling just short of glory only to be patted on the helmets as if they were incapable of being even average, much less victorious?

Fall 2024 to January 2026 seems as dreamlike as my surprising siblings or friends who found marvelous success and brought me joy in the process. So, has IU won the National Championship? I do not yet know. But I already know my Alma Mater is no longer the doormat of college football history. While I expect IU to beat Miami, I know they have already covered those hallowed southern Indiana limestone walls with laurel amidst all that ivy!

On Facebook follow us at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”

 

Want to see those southern Indiana limestone buildings! Click on this link for more:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCK0DpkswvY

Peg’s clean uniform for 01/19/2026 game. Photo by Peg Redwine

 

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: Football, Gavel Gamut, Indiana University, Sports Tagged With: College Football National Championship, Gentle Reader, hallowed halls of laurel, Indiana University football, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, southern Indiana limestone

  • Page 1
  • Page 2
  • Page 3
  • Interim pages omitted …
  • Page 6
  • Go to Next Page »

© 2026 James M. Redwine

Loading Comments...
%d