• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content

James M. Redwine

  • Books
  • Columns
  • 1878 Lynchings/Pogrom
  • Events
  • About

Fareed Zaharia

Change the Court

August 2, 2024 by Peg Leave a Comment

 On July 29, 2024, President Biden proposed that justices of the United States Supreme Court serve a maximum of eighteen years instead of “during good behavior” as Article III of the Constitution provides. On June 18, 2024 CNN Commentator Fareed Zakaria made a similar proposal. Biden and Zakaria are liberals who are upset with the Supreme Court’s current conservative majority.

In the turbulent 1950’s and 1960’s the Supreme Court was led by a liberal majority headed by Chief Justice Earl Warren. Much of America was so upset by the Court’s decisions on civil rights there were billboards on our nation’s highways calling for Warren’s impeachment.

It is not unusual for cases before the Supreme Court to cheer many and anger others. Matters end up in the Supreme Court because citizens have opposing views on hot-button issues. That’s what courts are for. It is better to go to court than go to war.

 Of course, if the public loses confidence in the justice provided by the Court, war could still result. According to Gallop polling from July, 2024, 52% of Americans disapprove of the way the United States Supreme Court is doing its job. Hence, we once again are hearing demands for “court reform”, which to the dissenters means changes that would create a court that agrees with their views.

The dissatisfaction that sways left and right with the Court’s decisions is improperly addressed to the individuals or contemporary majority. The solutions are within our constitutional republic’s power. We do not need to put up with frustration with the Court’s fallible humans; what we need is to change the way the Court is composed. And we have the power to do it. We have amended our Constitution 27 times already for such things as women getting the vote. We can amend it again to re-establish confidence in our third branch of government.

Rational minds can differ as to the details but the essence of reform is already apparent. America needs to reaffirm our commitment to our solid foundation of three equal and separate branches of our republican form of our unique democracy. First, we need term limits; I suggest that since our presidents can only serve 8 total years that Supreme Court justices be limited to 10.

Second, we need to change our method of selecting our justices. Currently only 101 Americans, out of over 330 million have any say in who serves on the Supreme Court. The single presiding president nominates a potential justice, for life, and the 100 members of the Senate “advise and consent” to the nomination. We need to involve the rest of America’s voters in these vital decisions. I suggest we develop a non-partisans competitive election where qualified candidates can be “vetted” by all of us.

I do have further suggestions, but as I have already written and published over 30 Gavel Gamut columns on the Supreme Court from 1990 to today, I’ll just make these “modest proposals” for now.

Perhaps we’ll meet again on these issues later as the complexity and importance of modifying an entire branch of our government may require more than a couple of pages from one columnist. Feel free to join in, Gentle Reader.

 

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: Gavel Gamut Tagged With: Chief Justice Earl Warren, Constitution amendment, court reform, Fareed Zaharia, Gentle Reader, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, President Biden, Supreme Court Justices general election, term limits, three equal and separate branches of government, United States Supreme Court

It Is Time

June 23, 2023 by Peg Leave a Comment

Sunday, June 18, 2023 Fareed Zakaria on his CNN show, The Global Public Square, introduced a segment about the United States Supreme Court by stating, “The Supreme Court is supposed to be the ultimate, safeguard of our democracy, but has the Supreme Court itself become a danger to our democracy? Is the Court today acting as a defender of democracy or a threat to it?”

Fareed’s guest was Michael Waldman of the Brennan Center for Justice at New York University. Waldman’s book, How the Supreme Court Divided Our Country, sets forth a central thesis: nine unelected, life-tenured people on the Supreme Court hold too much power for too long and they have become “very, very activist and extreme in their rulings”. Waldman’s position, and mine, is that the U.S. Constitution was designed to adapt to changes in our society and it is critical that the Supreme Court change also.

Zakaria and Waldman advance the idea that the justices’ terms should be limited, Waldman suggested a one-term term of eighteen years. I have long called for term limits for all federal judges plus revamping their selection process to popular elections, not appointments that involve only the president and the senate. I think eighteen years is too long. I suggest if our elected president can only serve eight years that a ten- or twelve-year term for judges is reasonable.

In order to encourage people to run for federal judgeships it seems to me it is in the country’s best interests that once a judge has served her or his term the retired judge continue to receive all pay and benefits during their lifetime as long as they do not seek another judicial position.

Judicial offices could appear on the normal ballot as a non-partisan position as needed. There should be minimum qualifications required, such as graduation from an accredited law school, passage of a national Bar Examination, an age of at least 35, the same as the president, and a clear record as to ethical matters. As in all contested elections the relative merits of the judicial candidates could be brought out by the candidates themselves, their supporters, their opponents and the media.

Surely when our Supreme Court is being accused of “holding too much power for too long” and of being “a threat to our democracy”, it is essential we make some fundamental, Constitutional adjustments. America may not yet be on the brink of disintegrating into legal and political chaos, but when that possibility is bantered about blithely on Sunday news programs, it is time to act.

Share this:

  • Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
  • Share on X (Opens in new window) X
  • Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp

Like this:

Like Loading…

Filed Under: America, Democracy, Elections, Gavel Gamut, Judicial, Justice, Law, News Media, Rule of Law Tagged With: Constitution adjustments, Fareed Zaharia, federal judges term limits and elections, holding too much power for too long, James M. Redwine, Jim Redwine, Michael Waldman, The Global Public Square, threat to our democracy, United States Supreme Court

© 2026 James M. Redwine

%d