
Columns
Faith and Fact

When John F. Kennedy ran for president in 1960, he was besieged by a large portion of the electorate because he was a Catholic. Kennedy was pressured to disavow his faith or forgo his run for the presidency. On September the 12th, 1960 Kennedy reaffirmed his faith and declared he believed there must be a complete separation of church and state. He won the election over Richard Nixon, a Quaker, but just barely.
Only 32 years earlier in 1928 Al Smith, a Catholic, lost in a landslide to Herbert Hoover due in large part to Protestant ministers who feared Smith’s religion and even suggested as president he would establish a direct connection between the White House and the Vatican.
In 2021 Joe Biden, a devout Catholic, won the presidency in a campaign where his faith was not even an issue. In 2026 Abdulrahman Mohamed Ed-Sayed, a Muslim, won the race for United States senator in the state of Michigan. His religious beliefs were a prominent factor during the campaign. A large segment of the American Christian community attacked El-Sayed simply because he is Muslim.
America’s anti-Muslims today are much as America’s anti-Catholics in 1960. Their professed faith that only their own religion is acceptable might be tested by reference to two sources: the United States Constitution and the teachings of Jesus. The First Amendment provides:
“Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment
Of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.”
Jesus set the standard for Separation of church and state. When asked about how a person of faith was to reconcile his or her religion with the Rule of Law, Jesus declared:
“Render unto Caesar the things which are Caesar’s,
And unto God the things that are God’s.”
The Book of Luke, Chapter 20, verse 25.
Perhaps those American Christians who base their political beliefs on what they say are their patriotic and religious duties should refer to the sources of those duties and beliefs.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
It Matters

Peg and I voted early; it felt good. The Election Office was “manned” by several women who were exceedingly competent and of good humor. Peg and I later spoke of the irony of the voting being operated by a crew made up solely of women when women were not allowed to vote until 1921. That was a significant move toward “a more perfect union”. Maybe we will work it all out eventually.
Lately, the national conversation concerning which citizens should receive equal rights centers around Muslims. While there did not appear to be any Muslims in line to vote, there were Native Americans, Blacks, women and a person in a wheelchair. All were afforded the right to vote with Peg and me although our Founding Fathers only originally enfranchised white, propertied, males over twenty-one.
I noted a couple of people who looked to be barely eighteen and they reminded me of when I was under twenty-one, I had no right to vote. That was true even though I was subject to the draft and the war in Viet Nam. Well, another part of the “more perfect union” was crafted by that change.
The right to vote reminds me of life in general. We start out as infants with no rights and, if we live long enough, often end up with no rights. In between, we are given many options that we did not start out with and are often taken away when we age.
Peg and I are not completely naïve. We realize our votes are much as raindrops in a thunderstorm. Heck, we had never heard of most of the people we had the option to or not to endorse. Nor did we expect our opinions on several Propositions to have any effect. However, just as an eighteen-year-old can now not only be ordered to kill or die but can also vote, we have the right to express our positions on our governors.
The right to vote has often been the harbinger of some ostracized group being assimilated and accepted into America’s Volksgeist. Too slowly and often only after bloodshed we have recognized that religion, ethnicity, language, culture or origin should not be used to deny to a group the rights guaranteed by our Constitution. Women, Blacks, Native Americans, Mormons, Jews, Japanese, Chinese, Catholics, Irish, Hispanics and others have felt the onus of prejudice. Now it is Muslims.
Today, our politicians and religious leaders are categorizing Muslims, Arabs and Iranians as less than human. Unfortunately, the news media and the general population have lost sight of our sinful past. People should have the right to the benefits of American citizenship based on their character and behavior, not the perception of their religion or culture.
When given the option to vote for inclusion versus prejudice, Peg and I seek to afford others the rights we wish for ourselves. Our votes may be insignificant to the universe but to us it feels so good and seems so right to express by our votes that we are, in our opinion, furthering along the progress toward that “more perfect union”.

You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
A Modern Lynching
In 1963 I dropped out of college in Oklahoma and wandered to California to see what was there. What I found was San Leandro in the “Bay Area”. The remnants of segregation were still ascendant in Oklahoma but in California homosexuality provided the target population. In cowboy country there were a few sissies but they were not considered threats to masculinity and no one imagined females combining. At that time, only male homosexuals were on anyone’s radar screen.
So, when I met guys in San Leandro who viewed queers with disdain I was perplexed. In my former world no one saw sissies as a dangerous genre that needed to be extinguished. But some of the young men I met in California categorized queers as “the others” who posed a threat to humanity. And one form of entertainment was to ride the city buses and identify queers to be beaten up. No one used the term “gay” back then except the Gay community itself.
When I was first encouraged to join in these forays I was perplexed. I had never been aware of the Gay lifestyle and had no emotions for or against it because it was a non-factor to me. Anyway, I never had any inclination to go “queer hunting”. But I was repulsed by those who did. Although I never voiced my revulsion or spoke against it. Occasionally a thought would meander through my brain that the queer bashing was much like my experience with segregation. And when these rare doubts arose, I sometimes found them interplaying with stories of witch burnings and the lynching of cattle rustlers and virile young Black men.
Now the mob mentality is often catalyzed by religion, especially Islam. Whereas in the days of segregation and Gay bashing terms were used to define Blacks and homosexuals as the “others”, today our American society seems fixated upon such terms as “terrorists” and “Mohammedans”. Even our elected leaders do not hesitate to call for Muslims to be discriminated against or even exterminated.
There was a time when our news media filtered the ignorance and evil of discrimination against groups who were easy targets. But today reporters re-spout hate without any notion of its harm. However, the greatest harm occurs when our political leaders treat Islam as unworthy of equal treatment with other faiths. Does it matter?
Yes! We humans often seek to ostracize groups who differ from us and then attack them for being different. This Lynch Mentality is used without restraint by our President and many members of Congress. It is one of the main excuses for our unprovoked war against Iran.
Of course, just as with Blacks, homosexuals, women and other mistreated elements, our prejudices came back to hurt us. I just paid $6.00 per gallon for diesel fuel and have given up ever eating another filet of good beef. We have spent billions of our tax money and lost the lives of several of our military personnel all for an immoral attempt to, as President Trump says, “To annihilate an entire civilization of 90 million human beings”.
Our mob mentality against Iran is fueled by a need to impose our will and we often refer to Iran’s religion as the justification. We appear to forget we have engaged in the same practice of religious discrimination against Catholics, Mormons, and even internecine battles between numerous Protestant faiths.
Of course, the solution can be found in our nations’ charter. However, we would have to not only read it but actually apply it.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
Publicly Executed?

The ironic observation, “Nothing is as frustrating as to be anonymously hanged”, is often attributed to the great English wit Samuel Johnson (1709-1784). United States Secretary of War Pete Hegseth wants the “honor” of a public firing squad to be given former U.S. Army Major and psychiatrist Nidal Hasan who murdered 13 unarmed people at Fort Hood, Texas on November 5, 2009. Hasan was convicted and sentenced to death by firing squad via a court martial trial in August 2013. The army panel also ordered Hasan’s dishonorable dismissal from the service and the forfeiture of all his pay and allowances. Our military likes to dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s.
The court martial panel heard the evidence concerning Hasan’s actions and determined in a sentencing hearing he should receive the death penalty. No mention of whether the execution should be public was offered during the court martial and sentencing. Apparently, Secretary Hegseth decided Hasan’s execution should be available to the world via live streaming.
It is predictable that much of humanity would be appalled by making Hasan’s execution a public spectacle. It is also predictable that much of the public would want to observe one of their fellow human being’s body being shredded by several bullets. But which segment of humanity has the moral high ground, if either? Those who squeamishly choose to not watch will not change the end result nor will those who find the experience ghoulishly intriguing. What also will not be changed by whether Hasan’s execution is public or by invitation only is the deaths of his 13 murder victims and his own. Of course, most people will take no note at all.
The brilliant French philosopher and penologist Michel Foucault (1926-1984) observed in his book, Discipline & Punish, The Birth of the Prison, that the public spectacle of executions had the effect of putting the public at the center of punishment. When executions are private and virtually anonymous the citizenry does not feel the responsibility of operating its penal system. Whereas, the public may prefer that miscreants be punished without the public’s direct involvement, what private punishment does is often remove the moral responsibility from what is one of society’s most moral dilemmas, how we as a society control others and punish them.
As for Nidal Hasan, he knows the bullets will have the same effect whether he is shot privately or publicly. He may prefer that the world see America’s justice system as America often sees those of other countries. The closely guarded inhumane procedures still being used at Guantanamo Bay prison should, perhaps, also be live streamed.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
Taking the Mantle

In Shakespeare’s Henry IV, Part I Prince Hal who will later be King engages in riotous living with John Falstaff and others. But when Hal becomes king in Part II, he assumes the responsibility of the monarch and rejects his prior immoral behavior. Falstaff does not understand or accept this change in roles. Hal calls his former partner in villainous behavior a fool and rejects Falstaff. King Henry tells Falstaff:
“Presume not that I am the thing I was, for God doth know, so shall the world perceive, that I have turned away my former self, so will I those that kept me company.”
This is the “Prince Hal effect”. A responsible leader must put off childish or bad behavior and govern in the best interests of the people. As advised in First Corinthians, Chapter 03, verse 11:
“When I was a child, I spoke like a child, I thought like a child; when I became a man, I gave up childish ways.”
Assuming the Mantle of Responsibility is particularly crucial for one who seeks and wins elected office. It is one thing to live one’s life on one’s own terms, placing his or her desires foremost. It is quite another thing to seek to help govern one’s fellow citizens then keep behaving and publicly speaking as an irresponsible miscreant or a feckless child.
When a seeker after public office campaigns on promises that raise the hopes of the electorate, a democracy is belied if those promises are not kept, especially if the elected official continues with narcissistic or immoral behavior. To seek and assume leadership of one’s fellow citizens implies the promise that former selfish behavior will be set aside and the official’s decisions will be consistent with his or her campaign promises. For a democracy to function in the best interests of the country, the leaders of that democracy must subjugate their former illicit desires to a desire to serve others.
America’s history is replete with elected leaders who sought the power to govern for their own ends. Fortunately, it was also built upon the selflessness and courage of the many who put away past selfish behaviors and sacrificed for the country. The Prince Hal Effect has often brought forth greatness from our leaders whose prior lack of promise was unexpected when crises had to be faced.
Unfortunately, the converse is also true.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”
Those People

Joseph Campbell (1904-1987) was a philosopher whose main concentration was comparative mythology. As we look to Campbell for guidance on war and peace, Gentle Reader, you might want to remember I am to understanding Campbell as a reporter is to understanding Artificial Intelligence. The same sort of puzzlement you may experience after reading my analysis of Campbell’s recitation of the age-old mythology of war is what I feel when a reporter with a degree in English stumbles around A.I. with Geoffrey Hinton. In other words, one would be prudent to rely on their own conclusions rather than to simply elide over mine when Campbell’s higher thoughts are an issue. With that product warning, let’s dive in.
Campbell wrote many books on mythology. One of my favorites is Myths to Live By. It is only 276 pages long. However, if you are like me, it will take you as long to digest it as it would James Joyce’s Ulysses. On the other hand, Myths to Live By is much more useful and interesting than Ulysses and, frankly, easier to understand.
In Campbell’s chapter on the “Mythologies of War and Peace” Campbell sets forth his central thesis as follows:
“For it is a basic idea of practically every war mythology that the enemy is a monster and that in killing him one is protecting the only truly valuable order of human life on earth, which is that, of course, of one’s own people.”
Campbell juxtaposes this philosophy with that of the great German philosopher Arthur Schopenhauer (1788-1860). Campbell cites to Schopenhauer’s essay “The Foundation of Morality” in which Schopenhauer asks:
“How is it that an individual can so forget himself and his own safety that he will put himself and his life in jeopardy to save another from death or pain – as though that other’s life were his own, that other’s danger his own? Such a one is then acting out of an instructive recognition of the truth that he and that other in fact are one.”
Campbell says such actions occur because we occasionally recognize that we are all one. Such actions are motivated by the one and only inspiration of inherently moral action. For a moment one is selfless, boundless, without ego.
This epiphany that we are all one is what Jesus was preaching about. Or as John Donne (1572-1631) put it in his poem, For Whom the Bell Tolls:
“No man is an island, entire of itself; … any man’s death diminishes me, because I am involved in mankind.”
So, the mythology of war is mainly between all “others” are monsters versus there are no “others” because we are all one. We must strive to defend ourselves and our fellow citizens from those “others” when they regard us as “the other”, but we will only achieve true peace when we and all “others” accept that we are one. While some defensive wars are still necessary for our survival, if we are to avoid extinguishing our species, we must accept all as we want them to accept us.
At least that’s what I got from Professor Campbell or I might have learned it by being horrified by the news. Of course, my wife Peg points out that other fine contemporary philosopher, John Lennon (1940-1980), said the same things in his song, Imagine. And it certainly is easier on the brain.
You can also follow us on Facebook at “Jim Peg Redwine” or Substack “@gavelgamut”